Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Seller’s and buyer’s views of an under-sink plumbing inspection.

A Six-Figure Repair Request. Now What?

A seller's guide to making sense of the inspection process.

  • Tregg Rustad
  • October 29, 2026
Your home is in escrow, the buyer's inspections are complete, and their 'request for repairs' has arrived.
Two Perspectives on the Same House
Buyers and sellers rarely agree on what counts as a defect, or how it should be corrected. It's easy to see why. A seller who has lived in a home for years knows which systems work and which quirks never caused a problem. A buyer is seeing the same house through another lens: a stack of reports, often with a contractor's estimate attached. That's one reason we attend the buyer's inspections when we represent a seller. Hearing the inspector firsthand shows us which findings concern the buyers most before a request ever arrives. Being on site also gives us the context to challenge a finding presented as a major, expensive problem when it's really a minor and far less costly one.
A Measured Response to Any Request
Some requests are well supported, and others read like an attempt to renegotiate the price. Either way, our advice to a seller is the same: respond in a measured, reasonable way. That usually means separating new findings from conditions that were disclosed or apparent before the offer was made and getting our own estimates where the numbers seem high. It can also mean treating health and safety items differently from requests that amount to upgrades. We recently represented the seller of a home that was only about 10 years old. Inspections turned up a few maintenance items, nothing significant. The buyers saw it differently. Represented by a relative, they submitted a six-figure request supported by a bid from another relative. It was not well received. After taking a moment to digest it, our seller responded as reasonably as they would have to a more modest request. Over a few rounds of negotiation, the buyers agreed to accept a fraction of what they had requested, less than the estimated cost of the items that needed repair, and the sale closed.
Repairs or Credits
Once the two sides agree on what to address, the next question is whether a seller can (or should) complete repairs before closing, offer a credit, adjust the price, or use some combination of these approaches. Completing the work lets the seller choose the contractor, but it also means overseeing the job, obtaining any necessary permits, absorbing any overages or surprises, and accepting the risk that the buyer isn't satisfied with the finished work. A credit or price reduction is often simpler and carries far less risk for a seller, since the buyer takes responsibility for the work after closing, and the transaction can typically close on schedule. When properly structured, the seller's financial contribution is limited to the agreed amount, rather than whatever the repairs ultimately cost.
Weighing the Alternative
If a buyer's final request is unreasonable, saying 'no' and starting over may be the right choice, but it helps to weigh the request against what happens if the current buyer walks away. The home returns to market without the momentum of a new listing. Material issues discovered during inspections, along with reports received, need to be disclosed to future buyers. Starting over doesn't mean starting with a clean slate. If the price in the current contract is strong, a backup offer or a new buyer may well come in lower, and agreeing to more than a seller normally would (or more than may feel 'fair') can still be the better financial decision. When the sale price is one the market is likely to deliver again, holding firm carries less risk. The strength of the buyer, carrying costs, timing the move, and current market conditions all factor into the decision.
Each case is different. A successful negotiation isn't necessarily the one where the seller concedes the least. It's the one that leaves the seller in the best position, whether that means reaching an agreement with the current buyer or starting over.
For both buyer and seller, a home purchase is an emotional decision as well as a major financial commitment. Working through inspection issues takes sensitivity, reasonableness, an understanding of the leverage involved, and respect for both parties' desire to complete the sale. 

Your Trusted Advisors,

Peter and Tregg

Copyright © 2026 Peter Maurice and Tregg Rustad. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use, reproduction, or distribution of this content is prohibited.

Work With Us

Put our 58+ years of combined experience and local expertise to work for you.
Follow Us